This Just In: Housing Prices Actually Linked to Income, Jobs and Mortgage Rates

Holy cow! I mean, if you had been listending to a Realtor the last 8 years, you might never have suspected this 2x4 of obviousness across the face. But it's true.

Wait a minute, you mean, income, jobs and mortgage rates determine..... Yep, there's this complicated thing called "fundamentals".

This is a fantastic article by Susanne Trimbath which restates the critical success factors for prospective homebuyers.

1.) Do I have enough income (take home after expenses and debts) to purchase a home at the market prices?

2.) Will I have a job in 6 months?

3.) How do current and future mortgage rates coincide with local home prices and my monthly take home budget?

This is the part where our hall monitor Realtor friends step in and remind us, in that I-never-sold-anyone-into-foreclosure-ever condescending manner, "real estate is local".

True.

But so too are jobs and incomes.

And last Friday, California and Orange County got some interesting news:

California, the worlds' 9th largest economy according to GDP numbers, has an unemployment rate of 10.1%.

Orange County California's unemployment has reached an all-time high since 1993 of 6.5%

So why is it that a 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath, single family home in Lake Forest, CA is priced at $650,000, or 6 times the median income here of approximately $100,000 per family?

If you were to go to Redfin, Trulia, RealtyTrac, or Zeus forbid, Realtor.com, you'd be surprised as to the homes available for sale in Lake Forest.

And you would be far from impressed.

In a word, almost all single-family homes in Lake Forest, California are over-priced pieces of crap. I'm dead serious here. Most of the homes for sale right now in February 2009 in Lake Forest are foreclosures, or trashed out short sale properties. Nobody who doesn't have to sell is trying to sell their home right now. The availability of quality homes for families with children, for example, to consider purchasing are few and far between. Most fence-sitters must not only cope with still unbelievable home prices (between $450,000 and $750,000), but also the reality that the home they might buy will be riddled with defects and necessary repairs. It's just a fact. And this I'm reporting AFTER the housing crash has supposedly occurred.



Paseo Verdura, Lake Forest, California, 350 days later, still $650,000.
Bank get's an A for stubborness, and an F for creativity.

I submit that parts of Orange County are still living in a dream world in terms of their asking prices.

Why?

Well, because the local real estate market is screwed up. Yes, Orange County is a nice place to live. A beautiful place. Perfect weather, oceans nearby, mountains nearby. I mean OC living has its' merits, and those should be priced at a premium of some measure. But single-family homes remain overpriced.

Earned incomes in OC are higher than the rest of the country. However, I suspect that job market uncertainty combined with ridiculous home prices that bear no relation to incomes will keep many on the sidelines through a difficult 2009.

2 Bed, 2 Bath Aliso Viejo Condo Awaits You. Just $430,000!

Aliso Viejo is a lovely Orange County community positioned south of Lake Forest and north of Mission Viejo, California.

16 Alicante
1,496 square feet in size ($287/sq foot)
2 bedrooms
2 bath
2 car garage
Price: $430,000
Last Buy Price: April 1993, $125,000

Assuming you can scrounge up $86,000 for the 20% down payment, you can finance the remaining $344,000 with a fixed rate 30 year mortgage. Monthly mortgage payment at a 6.13% mortgage rate from the local bank and presto: A monthly mortage payment of just $2,091.29. That was easy!

But wait a second. What do we see just down the road nearby?
Another 2 bedroom, 2 bath condo, slightly smaller in size, for $390,000!
A $40,000 difference!

87 Pamplona
1,213 square feet in size ($322.00/sq foot - WTF?)
2 bedrooms
2 bath
2 car garage
Price: $390,000 as of Feb 18 (holy crap!)
Original Buy Price: November 2006, $421,172 (holy crap again!)
Days on Market: 137 days (yikes!)

And dammit if both condos don't have brand new gas stoves!

Aarrrrghhh! Runaway!

Come on people! Let's get with the program, shall we!
The temporarily increased loan limits are starting to make no sense at all if people keep dropping their pants on price!

It's a great time to buy a house in Orange Count.....wait, no it's not.

The OC Register reports today what many have suspected for some time - that the OC housing market is in serious trouble. As of June 21, 2007 home sales are down by a total of 29% from 2006 (including single family homes, condominiums and new homes).

In Lake Forest, CA year to date home sales are down 48.5% in June 2007 compared to June 2006, but the median home price skyrocketed to $647,500.

John Lansner correctly points out that while the total OC median home price is the same as this time last year at $640,000, it is impossible to discern whether actual home sale concessions in 2007 are up or down compared to last year's exchanges (concessions include paying out closing costs and buyer agent commissions, etc.).

It's now July. The summer home sales spectaculars must be in full swing.

Can OC Realtors now, after 6 shaky months, look at prospective buyers in the eye - in that oh so"special way" that a mere computer cannot- and still proclaim: "Hey, it' still a great time to buy"?

They can't.

Denial California-Style

Don't worry, Californians.

California is not in a real estate crisis and doesn't figure to be in one soon.

Mr. Tom Elias of the Daily Breeze (L.A.) asserts that you can hardly go wrong when investing in California real estate. So if you are holding on to that home, or have recently purchased a home in the Golden state at top dollar, you're investment is surely "safe as houses". Indeed, California has experienced it's share of booms in it's history, but rarely are these booms followed by serious busts. Usually the declines are gradual and take many years to reach bottom.

Mr. Elias suggests also that "in-migration" will eventually save California's downward spiral housing market and preserve real estate values. Everyone wants to live here and this feeds the rational exhuberance of California housing demand. Rising tides float all boats. Soon renters earning $75,000 per year will be able to move up the proverbial California housing food chain and afford a home of their own. Though how this phenomanon is theoretically achieved is not precisely explained.

I thought I'd post this article by Mr. Elias to demonstrate the level of denial out there in the state about the California housing market. It is, in a word, quite unbelievable.

Mr. Elias' assertions might hold water if it weren't for some annoying little tidbits of fact facing potential homebuyers in California. The 2006-2007 housing crash, Mr. Elias, is different from previous boom-bust chronologies in California. What we are seeing is home financing for families with median to upper median-level income drying up almost completely. Lending standards are becoming more and more restrictive. While your "in-migration" may very well be increasing slightly each year in California, the incomes of those new residents are unfortunately not increasing proportionately with housing costs in California.

Overbuilt areas and non-overbuilt areas face similar music - that real median incomes in communities like Newport Beach, Long Beach, Irvine, Lake Forest, combined with the California-spend-it-if-you-got-it-lifestyle, simply do not support the magnitude of debt required to leverage a home. Becoming a homedebtor is still possible, but it's not something anyone in there right mind should consider right now. Mr. Elias' article fails to account for the mass emigration of people from the state of California due to housing costs (U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Finance) being "out of control", among other important reasons.

Even if Mr. Elias' assertion about "in-migration" were true, the notion that this influx of people searching for the good life would contribute to an economic rising tide in the state under which all boats would float, is fantasy. If anything, the result of such a theory would be that demand for rental housing in California would skyrocket to unprecedented proportions in the short run, but homes would remain unaffordable. In the medium to long run, housing values will fall substantially.

An almost perfect storm is brewing in Southern California real estate. Even those that would make the most from selling and financing homes, and who would walk over dead bodies and lie during the entire trek to preserve that earning potential, know this truth.

If you now own a home in Southern California, then you should be using every recourse to sell the living shit out of it. Drop your drawers on price, incentivise like no tommorrow, just get the f*#$ out!

If you are thinking about buying a home right now in Southern California, you should dunk your head in a cold bucket of water and then think again. Now is the worst time ever to purchase a home. Changes in the U.S. economy, the job market, the U.S. dollar, lending standards and price trends are aligning themselves to suggest one thing: Wait.

86 The Orange County Housing Market? Better to be patient.

The OC register reported this week that median Lake Forest home sale prices fell 19.5% when comparing YTD April 2007 with April 2006. This Lake Forest statistic of median home prices smashes the Orange County-wide stat of just a .2% price decline for the same period.

Total home sales in Lake Forest, California declined 24.7% in April.

Not a good time to buy. Not a good time to be owing on an asset with an increased likelihood of a future downward trend.

So should you "86" OC housing off your future "to-do" list. Perhaps, but not necessarily long term.

There can be no question anymore that a real estate recession is underway here in Lake Forest. But if more people would just stop what they're naysaying and listen closely to realtors and Mr. Yun of the N.A.R. , then perhaps the Orange County weather might eventually save the day and bring all of those sideline prospective buyers out of the wood work, with their front pockets lined with rainy-day cash, with FICO scores hovering in the stratosphere, and of course, W2's with above-median incomes - all of them patiently waiting to re-enter the candy store of creative California mortage loans to re-open.

Only I'm not too sure that those mortgage candy stores will ever re-open.


Yeah, it looks great, doesn't it? But most can't afford to partake.

So unless you're rich kid, beat it!